Collaborative Family Law
Article by John Crouch,
Attorney at Law, Crouch & Crouch, Arlington,
Virginia; (703) 528-6700; Treasurer, Collaborative
Law Society
Collaborative Law is a process designed to counteract some of the destructive
side effects of the adversary legal system, and resolve divorces and other
family law cases in the "enlightened self-interest" of the entire
family. It achieves this without diminishing lawyers' ethical duties to
clients, or clients' right to make their own decisions. Indeed, it requires
lawyers to make sure their clients have adequate time, legal advice, and
relevant information before making any decisions. Collaborative lawyers
are trained in the skills needed to combine dispute resolution with client
advocacy and advising, to help attain the elusive "Good Divorce."
A contract to hire the lawyers for settlement only
In collaborative law, both clients make a formal agreement to hire their
lawyers only to negotiate, not to litigate. The parties are not giving up
the right to litigate, but they can't do it with the same lawyers. The contract
says that if either party starts contested litigation, both lawyers are
disqualified and the parties will need new lawyers. This condition reduces
the stress and escalation that often gets generated even in divorces that
start out with good intentions.
Honesty
The other essential element of collaborative law is that under the contract,
everyone involved has to disclose all relevant facts. The clients' individual
retainer contracts with their lawyers also require them to be honest. If
they are not, the lawyer can withdraw, or end the collaborative process.
This process is not for clients who want to keep secrets from each other
about facts that are relevant to the settlement.
Keeping things orderly and productive
The lawyers are trained in an "interest-based" dispute resolution
process that is somewhat like mediation. Most of the negotiation happens
in four-way meetings. The meetings are carefully planned and prepared for,
in preliminary meetings between each client and his or her lawyer. The lawyers
confer ahead of time to finalize the agenda and discuss how to minimize
distractions, surprises and unproductive arguments that might come up between
this particular couple. In the meetings, the lawyers use techniques for
keeping themselves and the clients focused on the process.
No short-term pressures forcing long-term decisions
One of the best features of Collaborative Law is not that it avoids
litigation, but that it avoids hasty and soon-regretted last-minute settlements
driven by the schedule and demands of litigation. Settlement conferences
follow pre-agreed plans. No one is rushed through the process. On the other
hand, to discourage indefinite delays, firm dates are set for settlement
conferences.
When needed, there is typically a short-term agreement at the beginning
about temporary support and attorney's fees. People in Collaborative Law
cases do not use unfair advantages to force an unsustainable settlement.
Non-lawyer experts in Collaborative Law and Collaborative Divorce (SM)
Besides lawyers, Collaborative Law can also involve psychological coaches,
financial plan-ners, evaluators, mediators, appraisers, and child advocates,
depending on the needs of the case. They too are trained in collaborative
dispute reso-lution, and are disqualified, by the Collaborative Law contract,
from involvement in contested litigation. Collaborative Divorce (SM), a
proprietary service-marked service, predominantly uses a team of lawyers
psychological coaches and a financial planner. Like Collaborative Law, it
brings in other experts when appro-priate. Collaborative Law involves the
psychological coaches and financial planners when needed, but not in every
case. In either model, meetings with the lawyers don't always include the
other experts.
Collaborative Law and Mediation
The Collaborative Law process is run by two lawyers, each loyal to his
or her own client, rather than by a mediator who is concerned with remaining
neutral. Unlike in most mediations, each client has his or her own lawyer
available for legal advice and explanations.
Practice Networks
Collaborative Law began with four lawyers in Minneapolis in 1990. Now
there are at least 65 local/regional collaborative practice networks in
the U.S. and Canada. In D.C., Maryland, and Virginia, the Collaborative
Law Society (CFLS) includes over80 trained lawyers, financial planners,
and psychologists. For the most up-to-date list of
members, visit www.co-divorce.com.
Getting started
You and your spouse can begin by contacting a lawyer, financial planner
or psychologist on the list, depending on what
kind of help you need first.
For more information:
Disclaimer: Items are not to be considered legal advice
or to create any lawyer-client relationship. Most articles include some
obsolete information. In addition, taking any legal information out of context,
i.e., using it in a different court or a subtly different kind of case,
or without the training to understand all of what it means or doing research
to verify it, usually has disastrous consequences.